我依然怀疑，这未必是个浪漫鬼魂的故事，而是姑妈的一个执念。

她和那个坏蛋发生的事情都是真实的。她来到了岛上，无依无靠，想像出一个人。那晚坏蛋拿箱子时打死的那个人，分明是站在她一边的。开始她不知道他的名字，直到第二次进坏蛋窝棚，找到了一封信，才知道他的名字。她和他在一起时，从来是她动手，他没有真正挖过地，打过人，即使在两次危机时刻，她都只能靠自己，一次自救，一次掉进海里。

他的现身，有与坏蛋的互动，这是有点儿牵强。但是也可以理解为她在危机关头叫了他的名字，而坏蛋又是心里愧疚害怕过剩(过去关系应该也是过从甚密的)，所以有反常举动。只是最后他把坏人吓得失足摔死，确实是太离谱，从这一点，可以划归成奇幻。

现实中，没有人会拉她，她只能掉进水里，但是她依然坚信掉下去也会活着，因为他让她等。现实中，她被冲到岸边，遥对岛屿生活下来。他有弟弟妹妹的，所以多年生活中有后辈陪。但是一直没有等到他，直到她死了，他们的吻，才碰到一起。

这里的影评太少，贴一个其他地方找的:

Part National Treasure, part Titanic, Whisper Island is a very nice and charming fantasy about both a real treasure that two kids search for on an island in the middle of a lake in red state America and another more valuable treasure that a woman takes the full span of her life to find. Rebecca Hooper and her maiden aunt Reb Fleming are about to have their ranch taken from them as they owe a lot in back taxes. They write to another relative in Chicago, but instead get his teenage son Austin Archer instead who informs them that his father is deceased and he sure didn't leave any kind of money to help them out. Reb Fleming is one of those slightly addled aunts, but don't let her fool you she's had a most interesting life and it's fulfillment comes at the very end. All that's left is that legendary treasure where Archer and Hooper's daughter Rose Dalton take up the hunt. We also see in flashback Fleming's connection to the treasure and a romance of sorts she had with a mysterious stranger Ryan Wood. I enjoyed this very much and recommend it to family audiences. Just think about Rose in Titanic and it will all be clear.